View Single Post
  #2  
Old 06-11-2013, 11:34 AM
jforbes jforbes is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2013
Posts: 12
Default Re: Q17 and Q18 clarification

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elroch View Post
In these two questions there are the independent possibilities of E_{in} rising falling or staying the same and the same for E_{out}. In the latter case, while for the two inequalities the meaning is clear and based (with high confidence) on an adequate test sample, what the precise meaning would be for equality is not clear.

In any case, the options are not complete (there are 5 of 9), so presumably what is wanted is the greatest from those offered, regardless of whether it is actually the most frequent possibility?

In any case, could you clarify the precise meaning of the fifth option?
I used the same test set to evaluate the out of sample error for the alternatives, so it was in principle quite possible to get the same E_{out}. I'm not sure if this was the appropriate approach.

In principle though, what you're doing with your test set is you're approximating the true value of E_{out}, which you only approach in the limit of an infinite test set, in which case the probability that you get exactly the same E_{out} should be vanishingly small unless your hypotheses were the same exact function, which won't happen in our situation.
Reply With Quote